If you've tried renting an apartment in New York City lately, you already know the income requirements feel kind of crazy. Forty times the monthly rent as annual income minimum is the baseline. Some landlords want 50x. And if you need a personal guarantor, that person typically has to earn 80 to 100 times the monthly rent, which means for a $3,000 apartment, your co-signer needs to clear somewhere between $240,000 and $300,000 a year. We break that down more in our guide to NYC apartment guarantors.
These numbers aren't random or arbitrary. They're a response to the legal environment landlords in New York now operate in, especially since 2019. Once you understand that legal environment, the screening gauntlet starts to make more sense. But it is still frustrating to deal with. Luckily, there are some helpful solutions to getting approved quickly for an apartment in NYC.
The Law That Changed Everything: HSTPA 2019
In June 2019, New York passed the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act, usually called HSTPA. It was the biggest overhaul of landlord-tenant law in the state's history, and it shifted a lot of power toward tenants.
A few of the changes that still affect renters today:
Security deposits got capped at one month's rent. Before HSTPA, landlords could ask for several months of rent upfront as extra security when an applicant didn't quite meet their income requirements. A lot of borderline applicants got apartments that way. That option is gone now, statewide. As the New York State Bar Association noted in their analysis of the law, this removed one of the main tools landlords had for accepting higher-risk applicants. The law also banned prepaid rent, so the old "first and last months" arrangement isn't legal anymore either.
Evictions got a lot slower. Courts can now grant a stay of up to a year if a tenant can't find somewhere else to go. Before anything even gets to court, a landlord has to issue a 14-day written notice. The NYSBA's assessment was that under the new rules, many landlords would be unable to complete an eviction in less than a year, and that was the optimistic estimate given how much discretion judges have to push things out further.
Vacancy bonuses disappeared. Landlords used to be able to raise rent 20% between tenants. That's gone, which means a landlord who ends up stuck with someone who stops paying has fewer ways to recover financially on the next lease.
The intent of all this was to protect tenants from bad landlords and runaway rents. For a lot of people, it has worked. But the NYSBA also flagged who might get caught in the crossfire: "prospective tenants with no or poor credit history, newcomers to New York, and students enrolled in New York's many universities might be collateral damage of the new laws." That's turned out to be pretty accurate.
What a Bad Tenant Actually Costs a Landlord Now
The reason screening has gotten harder is pretty simple: the cost of getting it wrong has gone up.
An eviction in New York City isn't a quick process. According to Steadily's eviction cost guide, going from start to finish can easily cost $10,000 or more once you factor in legal fees, court costs, and months of lost rent. Snappt's analysis puts contested attorney fees at $150 to $400 per hour, with complicated cases clearing $5,000 in legal costs alone. TransUnion SmartMove research pegs average total eviction costs at $3,500 nationally -- the number in New York is higher.
The timeline makes it worse. The first court date isn't even a hearing, it's a conference. Cases get pushed out repeatedly. If a tenant files for emergency rental assistance, that alone can freeze proceedings for months. Each appearance costs a landlord half a day. One landlord writing about their experience described NYC Housing Court not as a legal process with a clear endpoint, but as "surviving a bureaucratic siege."
This is what's behind the math on screening. As our post on renting without a co-signer puts it: "The landlord isn't necessarily skeptical of you personally. They're applying a financial standard that exists because New York's tenant protections make eviction a slow, expensive process. They want a backup."
When a wrong call on a tenant application potentially costs five figures and a year of your time, you get very conservative about who you approve.
The Deposit Cap's Unintended Side Effect
The one-month deposit cap deserves its own section because it had a consequence that doesn't get talked about enough.
Before 2019, if a landlord was on the fence about an applicant, they could ask for two or three months of extra security. The tenant paid more upfront, the landlord felt covered, and the deal happened. It wasn't ideal for the renter, but it was a real path to getting an apartment.
That path closed. And what replaced it, from the landlord's perspective, was nothing. They couldn't take extra deposits anymore, they couldn't ask for prepaid rent, and evicting someone who stopped paying had just gotten more complicated and expensive. So they compensated by raising the bar on who they'd approve in the first place.
The Apartment Professionals Trade Society of New York said it plainly in their HSTPA analysis: the deposit cap "effectively limits the rights of applicants with limited credit or income levels to provide additional security to the Landlord to secure an approval when minimum screening criteria are not met."
This is a big part of why lease guaranty insurance has become more relevant since 2019. As we explain in our overview of how lease guaranty insurance works, it gives the landlord back the financial protection the deposit cap removed, while giving the renter a legitimate path to approval.
Who Gets Screened Out (And Why It's Often Unfair)
The people who end up on the wrong side of stricter screening aren't risky tenants. They're people whose situations don't fit the documentation model that landlords are using.
Recent graduates might be earning $60,000 and have no problem affording a $1,500 studio. But they can't hit 40x on their own, and if their parents are retired or live outside the country, there's no obvious personal guarantor.
International renters and students often have zero U.S. credit history. Even if they're financially solid by any reasonable measure, the standard credit check doesn't know what to do with them.
Freelancers and self-employed people earn real money, but they don't have regular pay stubs. A lot of landlords aren't equipped to evaluate that kind of income, so they pass.
Retirees may have a million dollars in assets and a pension, but if their income on paper is modest, an 80x requirement stops them cold.
Roommates run into a particular version of this problem. If you're splitting an apartment and one of you qualifies on your own while the other needs a guarantor, the default solution is to ask the qualifying person's family to co-sign for someone they may barely know. That's a real legal and financial liability to put on a family member, and in practice a lot of people just won't do it. The apartment falls through, or one roommate ends up shouldering the whole application burden. Neither is a good outcome.
None of these people are bad risks. They just don't fit the spreadsheet. Our NYC guarantor guide goes into more detail on who typically ends up needing a guarantor and why.
Good Cause Eviction: The Next Layer
HSTPA wasn't the last word. In April 2024, New York added Good Cause Eviction legislation, which extended tenant protections to a wider group of unregulated apartments. Landlords covered by the law now have to show a real reason to remove a tenant; they can't just let a market-rate lease expire and move on.
As LegalMatch notes, this "may increase the complexity of evictions, potentially leading to higher legal costs if a case is contested." For landlords, every approval decision now carries even more weight than before.
The broader trend is consistent. A BiggerPockets analysis put New York in a group of states with the most landlord-challenging regulatory environments in 2026, alongside Connecticut, Illinois, Massachusetts, Oregon, Maryland, and Washington. In every one of those markets, tighter tenant protections have pushed screening requirements up and made institutional lease guarantors more common.
What You Can Actually Do About It
The point of all this isn't to make renting sound hopeless. It's the opposite: once you understand why landlords screen the way they do, you can give them what they're actually looking for.
If you don't have a qualifying personal guarantor -- your family is overseas, your parents are retired, you're early in your career, or you're a roommate who needs to handle your own qualification independently -- lease guaranty insurance is usually the cleanest solution. Our guide on renting without a co-signer covers all the available options, but for most people in this situation, a guaranty policy is what actually works.
A professional guarantor company steps into the role a personal co-signer would fill. You apply, pay a fee, and get a policy document you present as part of your rental application. The insurer backs your rent obligations. The landlord gets documented coverage from a regulated company instead of hoping they can track down your relative if something goes wrong.
There's also a consistency angle that matters for larger buildings. As our post on what lease guaranty insurance is points out: "A personal guarantor might move, change their financial situation, or become difficult to contact. A policy from an established insurer is a stable document with defined terms." Property managers running hundreds of units would often rather process a standard policy than review a different person's financials for every application.
What to Look For in a Guarantor Company
Not all lease guaranty providers work the same way. A few things worth checking before you apply:
Is the company licensed by the New York State Department of Financial Services? If yes, it means they're regulated and financially accountable. This is a real bar, not a formality.
Who underwrites the policy, and what's their AM Best rating? The underwriter is who actually pays if there's a claim. You want an A (Excellent) rating or better.
How fast do they approve? A good apartment in New York can disappear in a day. Ask upfront what their typical turnaround is.
Can you get a human on the phone? Some services in this space are entirely automated. If you have a question during a lease dispute or at renewal time, that becomes a real problem. It shouldn't be hard to find out what their customer support actually looks like before you hand over money.
Common Questions
Do I need a guarantor to rent in NYC? It depends on your income and credit. If you earn less than 40x the monthly rent, most landlords will ask for one. Some will want one regardless if you have limited U.S. credit history. Our guarantor guide covers the specific thresholds in more detail.
Can my guarantor live outside New York? Most landlords want a personal guarantor in the tristate area so they can enforce agreements locally. Some accept out-of-state guarantors, but it's the exception. An institutional guaranty policy sidesteps this issue entirely.
How much does lease guaranty insurance cost? It varies by provider and applicant. For someone with U.S. employment, fees are typically in the range of 70 to 90% of one month's rent per year. International applicants without U.S. credit history generally pay more.
Can roommates use separate guarantors? Yes, and it's often the right move. If one roommate qualifies independently and the other needs a guaranty policy, each person handles their own side of the application. Nobody has to ask their parents to co-sign for someone they barely know.
Does a guaranty policy replace the security deposit? No. Most landlords still require a security deposit on top of any guaranty policy. The deposit covers damages when you move out. The policy covers rent payments while you're in. For more on the difference, see our explanation of how lease guaranty insurance works.
What's the difference between lease guaranty insurance and renters insurance? Renters insurance protects your stuff and your liability. Lease guaranty insurance protects the landlord if rent stops coming in. They're completely separate products, and having one doesn't affect the other.
What is Good Cause Eviction? It's a 2024 New York law that extended eviction protections to a broader class of unregulated apartments. Landlords covered by it can't remove a tenant without a legally valid reason. Good news for tenants once they're in. It also means landlords are even more careful about who they let in.
About PandaGuarantee
PandaGuarantee is a lease guaranty insurance company licensed by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Our policies are backed by an underwriter rated A+ by AM Best. We work with both renters and landlords, and we have actual people who answer the phone.
If you want to check your eligibility or just have questions, start at pandaguarantee.com.
For Renters | For Landlords and Property Managers
More from the PandaGuarantee blog: