Comparison Guide

PandaGuarantee vs TheGuarantors: Which Is Better for Renters?

Both services replace a traditional co-signer so you can secure an apartment on your own. But they differ in cost, eligibility, coverage, and where they're accepted. Here's what actually matters when you're choosing between them.

Start Your PandaGuarantee Application →

What Each Service Actually Does for Tenants

Both PandaGuarantee and TheGuarantors act as a lease guarantor—a third party that promises your landlord they'll cover rent if you can't. But the mechanics and the experience differ.

PandaGuarantee

A guarantee product designed to be straightforward for renters who don't have a U.S.-based co-signer or don't meet the typical 40x rent income requirement.

  • Replaces a co-signer or additional security deposit
  • You pay an annual fee—your landlord gets a guarantee
  • Application is online, with fast turnaround
  • Works with individual landlords and property managers
  • No need to involve family or friends financially

TheGuarantors

An established guarantor service primarily serving large multifamily buildings in major metro markets, particularly New York City.

  • Replaces a co-signer for lease guarantees
  • Also offers security deposit replacement products
  • Annual fee based on a percentage of rent
  • Primarily integrated with larger property management companies
  • Established presence in NYC rental market
Key distinction: TheGuarantors is typically offered to you by your building's management company as a built-in option. PandaGuarantee is something you can bring to a landlord proactively—useful when you're applying to apartments that don't have a pre-set guarantor partnership.

Cost Breakdown: What Renters Pay Out of Pocket

The fee you pay for a guarantor service directly impacts your move-in budget. Here's how the two compare on pricing.

Cost Factor PandaGuarantee TheGuarantors
Fee Structure Annual fee, percentage of rent Annual fee, percentage of rent
Typical Range Competitive rates, often lower for qualifying renters Generally 60–90% of one month's rent per year
Renewal Fees Annual renewal if lease extends Annual renewal required
Application Fee No separate application fee No separate application fee
Security Deposit Impact May reduce or eliminate extra deposit requirements Separate deposit replacement product available at additional cost
Payment Timing Pay at lease signing Pay at lease signing
Budget tip: When comparing costs, factor in the total move-in expense—first month's rent, security deposit, broker fee (if applicable), and the guarantor fee. A lower guarantor fee can meaningfully reduce the cash you need upfront.

Eligibility and Approval Process

When you're competing for an apartment, speed and flexibility in the approval process matter as much as the guarantee itself.

Eligibility Factor PandaGuarantee TheGuarantors
Minimum Income Flexible thresholds—designed for renters who don't meet 40x Typically requires some income floor, varies by building
Credit Score Considered holistically alongside other factors Credit check required; higher scores get better rates
International Renters Accommodates renters without U.S. credit history Accepts some international applicants, case-by-case
Approval Speed Same-day decisions common Typically 24–48 hours
Self-Employed Renters Accepts alternative income documentation May require additional documentation
Students Student-friendly with proof of enrollment + funding Accepted at participating buildings
1

Apply Online

Submit your information through PandaGuarantee's application. No paperwork mailed, no in-person appointments.

2

Get Your Decision

Receive a fast approval decision—often the same day—so you can move forward with your apartment application.

3

Sign Your Lease

Share your guarantee letter with your landlord. PandaGuarantee backs your lease, and you move in without a co-signer.

Coverage and What Happens If Something Goes Wrong

A guarantee is only useful if you understand what it actually covers—and what your obligations remain.

What does the guarantee actually cover?
Both PandaGuarantee and TheGuarantors guarantee your rent payments to the landlord. If you miss rent, the guarantor pays the landlord—but you still owe that money. The guarantee protects the landlord's income stream, which is why they accept you without a co-signer. It does not forgive your rent obligation.
What happens if I lose my job and can't pay rent?
The guarantor will cover missed payments to your landlord per the guarantee terms. However, you remain liable for those amounts. PandaGuarantee's team can help you understand your options if your financial situation changes, but the guarantee doesn't function as rent insurance for the tenant—it's a promise to the landlord.
Can I break my lease early with a guarantee in place?
A lease guarantee doesn't change the terms of your lease. If your lease has an early termination clause, that still applies. If you break the lease and owe penalties or remaining rent, the guarantor may be called upon to pay—and you'd then owe the guarantor. Always review your lease terms separately from the guarantee.
What if I have a dispute with my landlord?
The guarantee is between the guarantor and the landlord regarding rent payments. Tenant-landlord disputes about maintenance, habitability, or lease interpretation are separate legal matters. Neither PandaGuarantee nor TheGuarantors mediates those disputes, but the guarantee doesn't give your landlord extra leverage beyond what's in your lease.
Does TheGuarantors offer anything PandaGuarantee doesn't?
TheGuarantors offers a separate security deposit replacement product (essentially insurance that replaces your cash deposit with a smaller annual fee). PandaGuarantee focuses on the lease guarantee itself. Depending on your building, you may be able to use one service for the guarantee and another solution for the deposit, or your building may bundle them.

Where Each Service Is Available

Landlord acceptance is the practical gatekeeper. A guarantor service only works if your building recognizes it.

TheGuarantors

Primarily concentrated in New York City, with growing presence in a handful of other major metros. Most commonly available at larger, professionally managed multifamily buildings that have a direct integration with the platform.

NYC (primary) Select metros Large buildings Management co. partnerships

PandaGuarantee

Designed to work with a broader range of landlords—from large property management companies to independent landlords. Because you can bring PandaGuarantee to a landlord who doesn't already have a guarantor partner, it's more flexible geographically.

Multiple markets Independent landlords Property managers Renter-initiated
Practical advice: Before you apply to either service, confirm with your prospective landlord or building management that they'll accept the guarantee. If your building already partners with TheGuarantors, that may be your simplest path. If they don't have a preferred provider, PandaGuarantee gives you something to bring to the table.

Which Option Makes More Sense for Your Situation?

Hover over each scenario to see our recommendation. Your best choice depends on your circumstances, not a universal "winner."

Scenario

First-Time Renter Without a Co-Signer

You're signing your first lease and your parents can't (or won't) co-sign. You need a straightforward, fast solution.

→ PandaGuarantee. Flexible eligibility, fast approvals, and you can bring it to any landlord—not just buildings with existing partnerships.

Scenario

Relocating Professional Moving to NYC

You've accepted a job in New York and need to secure an apartment quickly from out of state.

→ Check both. If your target building partners with TheGuarantors, use them for speed. Otherwise, PandaGuarantee's renter-initiated model works anywhere.

Scenario

International Tenant or Student

You're moving to the U.S. without established credit history, a Social Security number, or a local co-signer.

→ PandaGuarantee. Built to accommodate renters without U.S. credit history. TheGuarantors handles some international cases, but PandaGuarantee's process is designed around this need.

Scenario

Renting at a Large Managed Building

Your building's leasing office already has a preferred guarantor service integrated into their process.

→ Use what's offered, but compare. If TheGuarantors is built into the building's system, it may be the path of least resistance. But ask if they'll also accept PandaGuarantee—you might get better terms.

Ready to Secure Your Apartment?

Skip the co-signer search. Apply to PandaGuarantee online and get a fast decision so you can sign your lease with confidence.

Start Your Application →
Apply to PandaGuarantee →